While I was in the warm, misty waters of Iceland’s geothermal spas, I realised how unique each one was. The Blue Lagoon and Sky Lagoon both offer wonderful experiences, but which one is the right choice for you? I visited both places one after the other to see them for myself.
One impresses with its volcanic landscape, while the other captivates with ocean views. One has a welcoming atmosphere for families, while the other has a stylish, grown-up feel. Winter visits brought a special charm—steam rising into the cold air, northern lights twinkling above. What surprised me the most was this.
Main Points
- Different environments: rough lava fields compared to endless coastal views
- Various crowd atmospheres—families, couples, and solo travellers
- Special practices at each location, including silica masks and seven-step spa experiences.
- Winter visits enhance the magical beauty of both.
- Accessibility is different; one is nearer to the airport, while the other is closer to Reykjavík.
What Makes Iceland’s Geothermal Lagoons Worth Comparing?
Geothermal bathing is a key part of Iceland’s culture, but these two locations offer very different experiences. First, there’s the history: one started in the 1980s as a trailblazer, while the other launched in 2021 with a stylish, modern look. Both use volcanic hot springs, but their atmospheres are very different, like lava fields and ocean cliffs.
The location is very important. The older lagoon is located 45 minutes from Reykjavík, making it perfect for quick stops during your airport travels. Are you referring to the latest version? Only 10 minutes from the city, combining beautiful coastal views with easy access. If you’re pressed for time, this could determine your trip.
But it’s more than just logistics. The waters at each location are different—one is milky and full of minerals, while the other is clear and refreshing. Families gather around the classic, while couples prefer the new infinity-edge design.
In the end, looking at these lagoons allows travellers to consider their choices. Do you value tradition or luxury more? Easy access or stunning views? I tried both to solve the code—here’s what you need to know.
Location: Practicality vs Beautiful Views
Iceland’s geothermal wonders are located in very different places, one surrounded by lava fields and the other by the ocean.Deciding between them begins with location—do you want convenience or stunning views?
A Warm Welcome
The journey to the first spa goes through lava fields covered in moss, creating a beautiful and rough atmosphere. It is 45 minutes away from Reykjavik, which makes it a popular stop when travelling to the airport. Steam rises from milky waters in front of a stark volcanic landscape—true Icelandic drama.
Views of the city with refreshing ocean breezes
Only 10 minutes from downtown, the Sky Lagoon is a delightful surprise. The entrance has an industrial feel, but once you step inside, you’ll find an infinity-edge pool that blends seamlessly with the Atlantic. Benches hidden among the lava rocks provide peaceful places to enjoy the scenery.
- Being close is key: Perfect for travellers in the city with limited time.
- Age is important: The 12+ rule maintains a calm atmosphere, unlike the family-friendly version.
- The pool’s design fits perfectly with the ocean, enhancing its impressive appeal.
Atmosphere: Suitable for Families or Just for Adults?
As soon as I got there, the atmosphere at each place shared a unique tale. One was filled with laughter and splashes, while the other spoke softly with elegance. Your choice may depend on if you seek energy or a break.
A Fun Place for Everyone
The first spa embraced families warmly. Children laughed in the creamy waters, while parents enjoyed the warmth of the steam. It felt like a vibrant vacation spot—imagine pool floats and selfie sticks. The experience was enjoyable, but it wasn’t really calm.
Calmness by the Ocean
The 12+ age rule at the Sky Lagoon established the atmosphere. Couples enjoyed cocktails in the infinity pool, where the edge blended seamlessly with the Atlantic. Secret corners and a swim-up bar grotto enhanced the charm. As the sun set, the water reflected the pink sky—there were no sounds, just a sense of calm wonder.
- Stylish baths: Carefully chosen spa cottages and simple design enhanced the atmosphere.
- The water here was clear, unlike its milky counterpart, and it reflected the horizon beautifully.
- Evening visits to see the Northern Lights provided an opportunity to watch the auroras while enjoying the warmth of the pool.
Water and Surroundings: Milky Blue or Crystal Clear
Testing both pools showed clear differences in their waters—one was cloudy like fog, while the other was transparent like glass. The first spa has a milky colour due to geothermal runoff filled with silica and minerals, while the newer one mixes in seawater for a clear look that reflects the horizon.
The magic of silica? After soaking, my skin felt very soft, but I discovered that I should apply conditioner to my hair first because the minerals can make it dry. The creamy water felt like lotion on my skin, while the clear option left no trace, just a cool, refreshing sensation.
The milky pool remained warm, perfect for the cold air in Iceland. On the other side, I found cool pockets of water near the edges, which created a fun contrast.
The first spa’s steam and blue colours made for striking photos, particularly at night when the lights shone brightly. However, nothing compared to the newer lagoon’s infinity edge at sunset—the clear pool blended seamlessly with the ocean, enhancing the beauty.
Here’s my conclusion. I really enjoyed soaking at night. As I floated beneath the starry skies, steam rising around me, both pools became magical retreats. However, the clear waters truly captured my attention with their beauty.
Packages and Pricing: What’s Included?
Silica masks and oceanfront saunas are what make these geothermal getaways special. Admission offers more than just a soak—imagine relaxing rituals, soft towels, and drinks with a beautiful view. The price is divided like this.
Mud Masks and Towels
The classic spa offers a Pure Pass for $73, which includes essentials like silica mud masks and a drink. I applied the cool mask to my face and rinsed it off in the milky water. My skin looked radiant afterwards. Towels are provided, but there is an additional charge for robes.
Seven-Step Ritual and Oceanfront Sauna
The Sky Pass at the Sky Lagoon costs $150 and offers an enhanced experience. A cold plunge and a scrub in a warm sauna with a view of the Atlantic follow the ritual’s opening steps. Every step promotes relaxation, culminating in a rain shower that made me feel wonderfully calm.
- The sauna has large windows from floor to ceiling that showcase the ocean beautifully.
- The drink debate: Cocktails are priced at $15 or more at both places, but the mimosa toast here seemed worth the extra cost.
- Private changing: Sky Pass offers quiet stalls that are better than the usual locker hassle.
Is it worth it? Yes, for a special occasion. However, if you’re watching your budget, the basic pass still offers a wonderful experience.
The Spa Rituals: Do It Yourself or Guided Experience
There are two spas, each with its own approach: one allows you to experiment with mud masks, while the other provides clear, step-by-step guidance. What is the difference? One feels like a fun experiment, while the other is a carefully designed spa experience.
At first, I took a scoop of mud that was rich in silica from a station. I applied it to my face and laughed at how funny I looked, but my skin really enjoyed the minerals. Washing it off in the warm water made me feel radiant. There are no schedules and no rules.
The second ritual had seven clear steps to follow. The cold plunge surprised my body at first. Enjoy a scrub in a steam-filled sauna first, then a cool rinse under a waterfall. Every step connected to the one before it, creating a harmonious journey to wellness.
- The bravery test involved a cold plunge during the guided ritual, which was chilly yet refreshing.
- The DIY mud scrub was enjoyable, but the pre-mixed scrub felt luxurious.
- Skin results: Both made my skin feel soft, but the seven-step method helped me relax more deeply.
The DIY option is more flexible when it comes to time. If you want a complete experience, the guided ritual is definitely worth your time.
Swim-Up Bars: Drinks with a View
There’s nothing like enjoying a cocktail while relaxing in warm geothermal waters. Both spas have great swim-up bars, but their designs are very different. One feels like a lively beach party, while the other feels like a hidden grotto.
Initially, I ordered a “Lava Sunrise” made with vodka, pineapple and grenadine from an open-air bar. The atmosphere was cheerful, with guests talking while enjoying their drinks. Is there a payment to be made? A waterproof wristband is a smart idea for enjoying a cash-free swim.
The new place impressed me with its cave-like bar. Their signature drink, “Ocean Mist”, made with gin, elderflower, and lime, went perfectly with the views of the Atlantic. Less mess, more elegance.
- Must-try drinks: The Sky’s herbal cocktails compared to the classic fruity blends.
- Non-alcoholic options: Both had fresh juices and sparkling mocktails available.
- Social atmosphere: One place is filled with loud laughter, while the other has soft clinks.
Here’s a great tip: enjoy a local Icelandic beer while you relax in the soak. The fresh coffee tastes even better with steam all around you.
Visitor Numbers and Ideal Times to Go
Timing is crucial when enjoying Iceland’s geothermal pools—I found this out the hard way. If you show up at the wrong time, your peaceful getaway turns into a chaotic scene. Here’s how to avoid the crowds and enhance your experience.
Shoulder Seasons Are Great
April to May and September to October have fewer people and more pleasant weather. Summer attracts tourists, but winter has shorter days, which leads to less time available. I went in October—I found this out through experience. News were just for me.
Tips for Dealing with Weather
Would you prefer rain or wind? Leave early. People stay away from the storms at noon, making the water wonderfully quiet. Here’s a helpful tip: Look at the weather forecast and be flexible with your booking. I saved 20% by moving my trip just one day.
- Dawn Patrol: The first slots from 8 to 10 AM are the least expensive and the most peaceful. Steam rises from the water, creating a magical atmosphere.
- Evening soaks during sunset are pricier, but they feel enchanting. Imagine soft candlelight reflecting on the water and the possibility of seeing the northern lights.
- Tip for Booking: Monitor prices for a week. Prices usually go down in the middle of the week when there are fewer tour groups.
For the best mix of value and atmosphere, try to go on weekdays at 11 AM or 3 PM. You can avoid the crowds and enjoy the warm sunlight.
Rooms and Facilities
Changing rooms may seem ordinary, but they showed the unique character of each lagoon. One focused on shared spaces, while the other provided private luxury. Your decision depends on if you prefer efficiency or enjoyment.
Regular yet Efficient
There were rows of lockers and benches in the basic setup. It was similar to a gym locker room—functional but busy during the busiest hours. Families liked the open layout, but there was a little less privacy.
The shower area had stations for free shampoo and conditioner. The towels were thick, but the robes came at an additional cost. Tip: Get there early to grab a locker close to the exit for easier access.
Enhanced Calmness
The premium pass came with a private changing lounge that had heated floors and views of the ocean. Vanities filled with luxurious skincare products after a soak make the experience feel like staying in a five-star hotel.
- Is it worth the extra expense? Yes, it’s suitable for couples or solo travellers. The soft and comfortable robes made the experience better.
- Family note: Standard rooms are better for groups because upgrades do not have shared space.
- In this comparison, premium locations featured Icelandic brands, whereas standard spots offered generic choices.
What’s my plan? I got the basic pass and went in the afternoon when there were fewer people around. For a special occasion, I would choose the private changing suite because that ocean view was amazing.
Tips for Skin and Hair Care
Soaking in geothermal waters is wonderful—until your hair becomes dry and rough. I learnt this the hard way. The high silica levels in certain pools can dry out hair and irritate skin if you’re not ready for it.
Coat your hair with conditioner before dipping. Keep it in—this helps block minerals. Use a light moisturiser on your face. Don’t go underwater if you have contacts in; silica particles might cling to your lenses.
After soaking, rinse well in the shower. The milky waters make your skin feel smooth, but they can block pores if not rinsed away. Softer pools with clearer water need less maintenance.
- For hydration, bring a leave-in conditioner spray for quick touch-ups while soaking.
- For sensitive skin, try a small patch test before using it fully.
- After your dip, use hyaluronic acid serum to keep your skin hydrated.
Here’s my helpful tip. Take a wide-tooth comb with you. Wet hair tangled with silica breaks easily. A quick detangle after rinsing helped my hair a lot.
Winter Visits: Tips for Staying Warm
Heated paths and icy walkways—my winter trip showed which spa experts provide comfort in cold weather. One leads you inside first, while the other has warm stones beneath your feet. Both options are effective, but the smooth transition kept me warmer.
Towels are very helpful. I placed one over my shoulders between dips—it became stiff but kept me warm. Here’s a helpful tip: Bring two. One can be used for drying, while the other serves as a wrap when you step out of the water.
Snowflakes falling into the pool made it feel magical. Not as enchanting? Allowing your hair to freeze. A cosy swim cap helped me after dealing with too many chilly ponytail situations.
- Choose wisely: Hot chocolate is better than cocktails when it’s cold outside. A cold cider with steam rising from it was surprisingly refreshing.
- Winter is the best time for saunas. I switched between steam rooms and cold plunges to improve my experience.
- When it comes to boots, waterproof slip-ons are better than flip-flops. My toes were grateful for the warmth.
Here’s a helpful tip: rent a robe. It brings a touch of luxury and shields against the wind during quick trips to the changing rooms.
Which lagoon captured my heart?
After experiencing both geothermal wonders, I found myself favouring one clear choice. The infinity-edge pool at the sky lagoon and its adult-only atmosphere were the highlights. What about the blue lagoon? It’s essential for those trying it for the first time.
I would rebook the Sky Lagoon immediately because the seven-step ritual was like a journey to a spa. What about the ocean views? Incomparable. The Blue Lagoon’s milky waters and silica masks provide a true Icelandic experience.
- For those looking for peace, Sky’s 12+ policy and quiet corners are a great choice.
- For families and newcomers: Blue offers a fun atmosphere and straightforward access.
- The swim-up bar grotto at Sky during sunset is truly magical.
If you desire luxury, choose the newer lagoon. If it’s your first one, begin with the classic. Each should be on your bucket list, but for different reasons.
Final Thoughts: Important Highlights
My trip to Iceland wrapped up with some clear favourites—here’s what made them stand out. The classic hot springs offer a rugged charm and leave your skin feeling soft and smooth. But the infinity edge and ocean views are amazing? Unmatched in luxury.
Schedule your morning appointments to avoid crowds and capture beautiful golden-hour photos. The new spa’s seven-step ritual is definitely worth the money. It’s important to book in advance—both places fill up quickly.
Having trouble deciding? Give both a try. Sometimes, combo tickets become available. If you’re fortunate, you might see the Northern Lights shimmering above while you relax. Make sure you don’t miss out—just grab your swimsuit and head out.
FAQ
Which one is nearer to Reykjavík?
Sky Lagoon is only a 15-minute drive from downtown, and Blue Lagoon is around 45 minutes away, close to the airport.
Can kids go to both places?
Blue Lagoon is great for families, while Sky Lagoon is better suited for teens and adults.
Should I bring my own towel?
Nope! Both places include towels with admission, but Blue Lagoon also offers a silica mud mask.
Which one has better views of the ocean?
The infinity pool at Sky Lagoon is right next to the Atlantic, perfect for enjoying waves and sunsets.
Is the water different in the two?
Definitely. Blue Lagoon has a milky appearance due to its minerals, while Sky Lagoon is clearer and has a touch of saltwater.
What is the “7-step ritual” at Sky Lagoon?
A relaxing spa experience—imagine cold plunges, steam rooms, and scrub treatments—all with a view of the sea.
Can I have a drink while I soak?
Absolutely! They both feature swim-up bars. Enjoy a Skyy Martini at Sky Lagoon or a lava smoothie at Blue Lagoon.
What is the best time to visit when it’s less crowded?
Avoid crowds by going early in the morning or on weekdays. By noon, Blue Lagoon becomes crowded with tour buses.
Are there private changing rooms available?
Available exclusively at Sky Lagoon (for an additional charge). Blue Lagoon offers shared stalls along with increased locker space.
Will the minerals damage my hair?
Maybe! Apply the provided conditioner before entering—both areas have a lot of silica.
